Always free. No spam.           Unsubscribe anytime.

A Radical Christian Perspective on Waging Peace in Our World

Israel: Few Rights, Many Responsibilities

Gemini Generated Image 5a1xus5a1xus5a1x

The Scope of the Problem

Last week I discussed the illegal nature of Israel’s founding. This week I wish to delve into what rights and responsibilities Israel has as a nation in the international system. What do the relevant treaties say about Israel’s rights and responsibilities in its dealings with the Palestinians?

The argument put forward is that Israel has few rights in relation to the Palestinians, and many responsibilities. The most reasonable interpretations of the relevant resolutions under international law point clearly in this direction. Not only that, but concern for basic human rights will also point in this direction. In short, Israel has no legal right to “self-defense” in relation to Gaza. In fact, it has an obligation to withdraw from occupied lands, and, until it does, to care for and protect the people under its occupation.

Since I take the position that governments are all criminal enterprises, international law should carry no moral weight. However, in the reality of a fallen world we are seeking some basic harm reduction, such as the cessation of genocide and the oppression and exploitation of populations. To that end, international law can provide some useful guardrails against excessive behavior. It can serve as a means of mitigating the worst instincts of these criminal entities we call nations. This is especially true given that these are rules that states designed for themselves to follow, which makes the term illegal the correct one. So, while not ideal by any means, international law can serve the cause of harm reduction and a reduction in violence.

Of course, all of this matters because of the Golden Rule. No one wants to be exploited, have their land stolen, or be forced to live as a second-class citizen. Therefore, no one should sit idly by while this is being done to innocent people. Additionally, the care and protection of the least of these is of great importance to God. I would submit that there are few, if any, groups more downtrodden and marginalized in this world than the Palestinians. We would be failing to give clear witness to our imitation of Christ if we remain silent about these issues.

Israel: A History of Land Grabs

From the time of Israel’s illegal founding, its history has been a series of land grabs. This drive to acquire land in this region has been a consistent idea since the emergence of Zionism in the late 19th century. It is a part of the so-called “Greater Israel” project, which saw the boundaries of biblical Israel as its borders. This is ironic considering the general prohibition on taking land from others. Isaiah 5:8 (NIV) speaks directly to this: “Woe to you who add house to house and join field to field till no space is left and you live alone in the land.”

After the initial war that followed Israel’s declaration of nationhood, Israel established its borders along the so-called “Green Line.” The 1949 armistice that ended the initial war said these were not political borders. Later, the international community came to view these lines as the baseline of Israel’s territory. Also, Israel declared West Jerusalem as its capital. This occurred at the same time as Palestinian Arab citizens of Israel inside the Green Line were placed under military rule. This lasted until 1966, but Palestinians being treated as second-class citizens did not.

Consider the 1967 Six-Day War, which Israel started, according to Menachem Begin, who stated “In June 1967 we again had a choice. The Egyptian army concentrations in the Sinai approaches do not prove that Nasser was really about to attack us. We must be honest with ourselves. We decided to attack him.” During this war Israel captured the West Bank and East Jerusalem from Jordan. It captured the Gaza Strip and the Sinai Peninsula from Egypt, and the Golan Heights from Syria.

In 1980, the Israeli Knesset passed the Jerusalem Law, which officially declared Jerusalem the “complete and united” capital of Israel. The next year Israel passed the Golan Heights Law extending its laws and administration to the Golan Heights region.

Israel did return the Sinai to Egypt in 1982 as a part of the Egypt-Israel Peace Treaty signed in 1979. Also, it dismantled all settlements and withdrew its military from Gaza in 2005. Yet, it retained control of airspace, territorial waters, most crossings, the population registry, and the entry of goods. Such was this control that international authorities still consider the Gaza Strip occupied.

Then there is the de facto annexation of the West Bank due to the presence of so many Israeli settlements all strategically placed to erase the border between this territory and Green Line Israel.

All of this is important because it sets the stage for how these issues were treated under international law. That will prove dispositive in establishing Israel’s lack of any sovereign rights over these territories as well as its obligations.

Israel’s Lack of Rights Under International Law

Israel and its supporters have long claimed, up to and including its response to the Hamas attacks on October 7, 2023, that Israel has the right to defend itself under international law. Article 51 of the UN Charter specifically allows defense of a nation until the Security Council has taken measures to maintain peace. It is clear that Israel has no such rights under Article 51. Israel’s claim is weak, and the International Court of Justice said so. In 2004 the Court ruled that Article 51 does not apply when a threat comes from a territory the state in question occupies.

Gaza is occupied territory, as was indicated above by the relevant international authorities. Israel has control of much of Gaza, including maintaining the right to enter at will with military force to “mow the grass”—that is, kill suspected Hamas members. Since, as the Court held, Article 51 governs interstate conflict, it may not serve as the basis for Israel to claim the right to self-defense against Hamas by attacking the Gaza Strip. It is nonsensical for a nation to have occupational control of a territory and then attack that territory under a supposed right of “self-defense.”

This would then place the response in a law enforcement framework. Under this view, instead of going to war under a stretched interpretation of Article 51, Israel would be bound by international humanitarian law governing occupation. This would restrict the use of force inside Gaza to the use of police powers to maintain order.

In fairness, we must examine the main counterargument. There were separate and dissenting opinions in the 2004 International Court of Justice case, arguing that Article 51 does not require an armed attack to come from a state, and that a nation must be able to defend itself against non-state actors, such as Hamas.

This is only partially accurate. There is certainly a case that any nation, including Israel, may defend its borders, and those within its borders from attack. That means that Israel would be justified in defending Green Line Israel from such an attack, which it did within days of the October 7, 2023, attack. Since Gaza is outside Green Line Israel, which is the baseline for Israel’s borders until a permanent settlement is reached, it may invoke Article 51 only to defend that territory.

All international authorities have rejected Israeli sovereignty over Gaza, the West Bank, East Jerusalem, or the Golan Heights. Therefore, there is no Article 51 right to defense against a territory that Israel occupies. Even if one accepted the minority opinion, the laws of war would prevent Israel from exhibiting such disproportional disregard for the lives of noncombatants. Rather than Article 51 rights of defense in relation to Gaza, Israel has obligations under international law, to which we now turn.

Israel’s Obligations Under International Law

Next we must examine Israel’s obligations under international law regarding its land theft. After taking land after the Six-Day War in 1967, the UN Security Council unanimously passed Resolution 242. This required Israel to withdraw from these conquered lands. Israel accepted this Resolution. Israel later claimed that the text provided room for interpretation. This smacks of opportunism. Requiring Israel to withdraw is more in keeping with the UN Charter, which views acquisition of territory by force as unacceptable.

The UN Security Council strengthened this by passing Resolution 338 after the 1973 Yom Kippur War. It reaffirmed Resolution 242 and called for negotiations to produce a long-term agreement.

Regarding other actions taken by Israel and the lands it stole, the UN Security Council spoke clearly about these as well. Resolution 478 declared the 1980 Jerusalem Law null and void. Resolution 497 declared the 1981 Golan Heights Law null and void.

Regarding the treatment and protection of people in an occupied area, Israel has obligations that it is obviously ignoring. Israel is a party to all four 1949 Geneva Conventions. These conventions are the international standards regarding treatment of victims of war. They cover everything from the protection of sick and wounded to the treatment of prisoners of war, and, most importantly, the treatment of civilians during war (the subject of the Fourth Convention). It is true that Israel did not ratify the 1977 Additional Protocols I and II, which is of little consequence as the international consensus is that the Fourth Geneva Convention covers Israel’s conduct in Gaza and the West Bank. This includes the International Committee of the Red Cross as well as the United Nations itself.

It should be said that the State of Palestine, recognized by 157 nations, agreed to the Geneva Conventions in 2014. In any event, Hamas is obligated under normal humanitarian law, regardless of whether Palestine is a party to these conventions. This would make the intentional targeting of innocent persons on October 7, 2023, a war crime. Experts have acknowledged as much, in case anyone thinks this is just so much cherry-picking.

It is true that Israel has the right to maintain order in an occupied territory, as you can see in Article 43 of the 1907 Hague Regulations and Article 64 of the Fourth Geneva Convention. These rights are police functions only, not an excuse to make war upon people in an occupied territory. However, these powers exist only while the occupation lasts. That does not remove Israel’s obligation to end its illegal occupation.

Israel has clear obligations under the Fourth Geneva Convention. Article 33 prohibits collective punishment. Article 49 prohibits forced transfer of populations. Article 49(6) also prohibits moving its own civilian population into an area, as in the West Bank. Article 53 prohibits the destruction of property not required for military operations. Articles 55-56 require the occupier to provide enough food and medicine. Article 59 requires an occupier to allow relief to be brought in. It is obvious that Israel is ignoring all of these specific obligations.

It is clear that the weight of international law, reaffirmed in July 2024 by the International Court of Justice, comes down against Israel as an occupying power that is ignoring even the most minimal standards of humanitarian conduct in Gaza. It shows Israel as a nation that has no right of war against Gaza. Israel only has limited powers and many obligations as an occupier. The most important among these obligations is to end the occupation “as rapidly as possible,” an obligation that it ignores.

The Only Nation That Matters Here

It is only the United States that matters in the enforcement of Israel’s obligations. As its main financial, military, and diplomatic patron, the U.S. is in a unique position to stop Israel from its barbaric treatment of the Palestinians and its steadfast refusal to honor its international obligations. As the strongest nation on earth (for the moment), the U.S. could change Israeli behavior with a phone call, as President Reagan did in August 1982. Israel simply cannot go forward with its land grabs alone, as was dealt with in last week’s post.

The question is how the U.S. governing elite can be persuaded to change course. There is enough democracy left (not that I am a fan) that popular sentiment still matters. As was discussed last week, Israel’s reputation is dropping in the U.S. This is especially true in the Democratic Party. If this translates into enough of a swing to a Democratic-controlled House of Representatives, with a stronger progressive left faction, and perhaps the Senate, then policy might change.

The longer-term solution is to continue to highlight the misdeeds of the rogue nation of Israel. We must continually put the spotlight on Israel’s lack of a legal basis to attack Gaza the way that it has, and to focus on the obligations that it has toward those under its occupation.

The followers of Jesus should be at the forefront of this effort. If we remain silent, then we accept what is being done. God never calls His people to silence. We must embrace the Golden Rule and insist that Jesus would never accept the sin of silence from His followers. It is incumbent upon those of us who have a clear idea of what it is to imitate Christ to separate the faith from the false prophets who would justify spilling copious amounts of innocent blood based upon a deeply flawed theology. Let us, with clear eyes, understand the basic rights (or lack thereof) and responsibilities that Israel has in the international system. Let us then take that knowledge and give effective, true witness toward helping reduce the violence, and do so in the name of a God who is without limit in His love for His people.

Praise Be to God

Related Posts

Scroll to Top